Awards Comparison - US vs The Commonwealth

Let’s compare America to British, Canada, and Australia when it comes to military medals for combat valor and performance. The British system was used in Commonwealth countries (including Canada) up to and through World War II. This began to change as countries such as Canada, Australian, and New Zealand started to create their own systems of honors in the 1960’s. 

The year 1993 saw a major change in all Commonwealth countries’ honors. The formerly overseas territories, such as Canada and Australia, fully created their own system of military awards separate from that used by Britain. Further, in Britain, the military awards system there removed distinctions of rank within the awards. Now enlisted and officers would receive the same award for the same performances. Previously, there were separate awards for officers and enlisted. 

COMPARATIVE AWARDS

British and Continental countries have long, complicated histories. This can make it hard for Americans (such as myself) to know what I’m looking at. Many countries award knighthoods to military members, sometimes for combat bravery or performance, as well as have civil and military orders of chivalry. Since those are usually awarded for long and faithful service, I won’t get into those and will show just purely military decorations. I’m also not going to examine awards for purely meritorious service outside of a combat zone. 


To complicate things, some of the British and Canadian decorations (in particular the non-combat bravery awards) can be given to all citizens, not just members of the military.

Hopefully this chart and article can help someone else make heads or tails of another country's medals for bravery and wartime service. If nothing else, it'll help me keep track of things as I write more articles about my brothers and sisters from across the pond.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Why does the US military not have a Company J?

A recent comment over at valorguardians.com pointed out that there has never been a company “J” in the US Army, leaving the letter J to be a bit lonely and left out. Being a student of military history, I realized that I’d never heard of a company J, but there are India, Kilo, and Lima companies in most modern 3rd battalions. So where did the missing J go and why? First come the popular, modern theories. These are the ones brought up by scuttlebutt, rumor, and theories passed down from generation to generation as gospel. Most of these have to do with the phonetic alphabet used. Most people if you ask now would say the reason for there not being a company J is that no self-respecting man wants to be in “Juliett” company. Apparently serving in a company with a woman’s name would be too emasculating. While on its face, this might seem like a plausible and entirely reasonable explanation to a young inquiring private, it doesn’t pass the sniff test. Is “India” any less effeminate? By
Read more

Adolph Metzger, the Valiant Bugler

Image
I am always awestruck by the stories of bravery of our fighting men and women. However, to be awarded a medal for any bravery, said bravery must be witnessed. I suppose this is a reasonable caveat as otherwise a lone survivor would be able to write his own story of derring do. It is therefore interesting for me to think of all the people who did obscenely brave things that were never witnessed and thus never rewarded. One example I'll give of this is Private Adolph Metzger, Company C, 2nd US Cavalry. From Württemberg, Germany, he first enlisted in 1855 in Philadelphia, listing his vocation as "laborer". Enlisting the in the Army was somewhat common for German immigrants in this time period so they could better learn English. Germany still operated under a guild system for tradesmen, so once immigrants learned English they could use those learned skills in the open marketplace here. His enlistment noted that he was 21 years old, 5'5" tall, and describ
Read more

Double Victoria Cross Recipients

Image
The Victoria Cross (VC) is Britain’s highest honor. As with the American Medal of Honor (MoH), it is not only the country’s highest award overall, but is awarded solely for combat bravery. Both awards were instituted about the same time, with the VC being created in 1856 and the MoH in 1861. Since then 1,358 VCs have been awarded compared to 3,524 MoHs. While there have been 19 double MoH recipients, only three men have earned a second VC. These are my subject today. Arthur Martin-Leake, VC & Bar, VD Photo Circa 1902 Arthur Martin-Leake hailed from Hertfordshire, England where he was born in 1874. Schooled as a physician, he enlisted with the Imperial Yeomanry during the Second Boer War that started in 1899. The Yeomanry was a volunteer mounted infantry force that first left for South Africa in 1900. The Boers were Dutch-speaking inhabitants of the eastern parts of South Africa that did not take kindly to British rule. During the First Boer War, the Boers had won some i
Read more